Sustainable or Regenerative?

written by

Josh Bauman

posted on

April 16, 2021

Sustainable this, sustainable that, we’ve all heard this buzz word being tossed around and used to describe pretty much anything. Eventually it’s just a word that doesn’t really mean anything. Sustainability in it’s original form is a great thing, essentially meaning that an organization or practice can go on without “running over itself”. When it comes to sustainability in agriculture, a lot of the focus naturally goes to soil health. We don’t want to be exporting more nutrients from the soil than we are giving back, or else we will be, as the proverb goes, “cutting off the branch we are standing on”. While it’s true that many modern agricultural practices are not sustainable, this word has been over used and any meaning or differentiation that it represents has become blurred.

In the past few years, there has been a lot of focus on the idea of “regenerative agriculture”. This term entails many of the same ideas as the original “sustainable”, with perhaps more of a proactive approach to improvement and rejuvenation of soil, rather than just sustaining the original. Along with this, the goals of regenerative agriculture include reducing or eliminating synthetic fertilizers and pest/weed control, increasing yields and productivity, promoting biodiversity instead of mono-culture, water conservation, soil conservation, and carbon sequestration. I will go over some examples of ways in which regenerative agriculture is being facilitated.

Synthetic fertilizers and weed control, are they essential? On most cropland today, the answer is yes. In order to get a profitable crop, you need to use these materials, and complete elimination of these things within a year or two is not going to be possible in most cases. I view fertilizers and pesticides somewhat like energy drinks. Does it give your land a boost? Yes. Is it a healthy, sustainable solution for long term crop production? The data would indicate that it is not. It’s only a matter of time before species (whether bugs or weeds) become resistant to pesticides, and in general, soil health is going downhill. What is the answer? In most cases, the solution is to start using regenerative practices and view the elimination of synthetic fertilizers as a long term goal rather than an immediate protocol. Once you have proper biodiversity, good soil structure, and a properly balanced ecosystem, very little additional fertilizer and weed control is needed. Perhaps the most efficient way of doing this is implementing livestock into crop rotation. By grazing livestock on your land, you are returning 80% of the nutrients and plant material to the soil vs. returning about 10% and exporting 90% when you harvest a crop. Right along with this subject goes the topic of carbon sequestration. Crop producers who have started grazing livestock on their land as part of their crop rotation have reported major increases in the levels of carbon and organic matter in the soil. This means that carbon is coming out of the atmosphere and going into the soil. The increase in organic matter in turn improves the soil’s water and nutrient holding capacity, and makes it more drought resistant. In a bio-diverse environment, plants and animals supply each other the nutrients that they need, and balance each other, producing a healthy, thriving ecosystem.

What is biodiversity? This term refers to the practice of incorporating multiple species into an agricultural operation, instead of focusing on one crop (a mono-culture). The nutrients that any given species needs can be supplied by another plant or animal, and so by promoting a bio-diverse environment, each species is benefited by the other species that grow on the same land. This creates a healthy balance that can support itself, and not only maintain, but improve soil structure.

In order to maintain sustainability, I believe we need to revolutionize the agriculture industry to a more regenerative approach. Initially, crop yields have been shown to decrease by a maximum of 30% when switching to regenerative methods. However, because the input costs are so much lower, properly managed regenerative operations are on average 75% more profitable than conventional operations. Plus, over time, as soil is restored, yields tend to climb to the previous levels of production or higher. In addition to the monetary benefits, regenerative methods have a net zero, and can even have a positive effect on the environment.

Thanks for reading, and keep your smile on! 🙂

God’s in control, so if you’re on His side there’s nothing to worry about.



More from the blog

The Greenwashing Epidemic

In the past few years, greenwashing, or deceptive labeling has been very prevalent in the food industry. For example, depending on the protocol of a company, only 25% of the ingredients in a product may need to be sourced locally in order to label it as "Locally Sourced Ingredients" Finding a farm that is transparent and honest in everything they do is the key for you as a consumer to avoid getting tricked into buying something that is not what it appears to be.

Hanging Weight vs. Packaged Weight

In this blog, I will address a sometimes confusing topic that comes up when a quarter, half, or whole beef or hog is purchased. What’s the difference between hanging weight and cut weight? Hanging weight is the recorded weight after the animal has been killed and dressed, but not deboned and broken down into cuts. It is the weight of the dressed carcass, bones and all. Packaged weight is the recorded weight after the carcass has been deboned and cut into steaks, roasts, ground meat, etc. So the packaged weight is the actual weight of the meat you put in your freezer.

What is Pastured Pork?

What is pastured pork? Well, first, as the term suggests, pastured pork is raised on pasture. However, because pigs are not ruminants, grass is only a part of their diet. The high quality forages that the pasture provides are usually supplemented with a grain ration of some sort. Pigs are characteristically determined to generally destroy anything they can get their snouts on, and so pasturing pigs takes some added management to ensure they don’t overturn every bit of grass in sight.